In Other News

Product index

The jackets, at a glance.

Drag through the jackets, then scroll through the argument.

Drag to browse · Click to read
BETTER · 04 OF 07Ralph Lauren · Leather Newsboy

$1,295

Ever since Mary had a little lamb, a leather jacket has been the coolest thing a man can wear. You know it, I know it, your girlfriend knows it. Plain and simple.

Brands know it too. It's in their top search terms, their assortment plans, and on the Fall/Winter runway every year. And you can't escape the throwbacks. Brad Pitt in Fight Club, Arnold in Terminator, every fashion account spamming Jacob Elordi fit pics, a guy who in my opinion dresses about as well as 80% of the men in lower Manhattan.

So the demand is obvious. Which makes it strange that a good one is so hard to find. Is it the demand? The price? Or is it that a decade of Hedi Slimane dick riders jacked up every Dior Homme and Saint Laurent jacket on the resale market? Probably that.

Anyway, I'm in the market too. I looked at seven jackets from $600 to $5,750 and read the spec on every one. Here's what the money actually buys, and where it stops buying anything at all.

GOOD

At Good, you're not choosing how much leather you get. You're choosing what kind of wear you want. Lamb for softness now, cowhide for softness later.

Banana Republic Racing JacketCompare options →

Banana Republic

Racing Jacket

Lambskin, which is the trade-off to understand at this price. Lamb is soft immediately and drapes better than anything else here, but it's a thinner hide, so it scuffs and wears through where cowhide would just patina. The tell that this is the budget option isn't the leather, it's the lining: cotton flannel in the body where the others use Bemberg. If you want a jacket that feels broken in on day one and you're not trying to hand it to your kid, this is the best-wearing thing at the price. Only comes in brown, and it's dark enough that it works with black.

$600Retail
Compare OptionsShop New
J.Crew Flight JacketCompare options →

J.Crew

Flight Jacket

This one names its tannery, which almost nothing at this price does. Conceria Montebello, Italian, in business since 1967. Naming the tannery means they're paying for the hide rather than sourcing whatever's cheapest that season, and the description confirms it: the leather starts stiff and softens with wear, which is what a heavier, less-processed hide does. Lambskin never does that because it's already soft. The A2 cut sits at the hip, which shortens the jacket and elongates the leg. I don't love the quilted lining, it makes the whole thing warmer and bulkier than it needs to be, but the collar popped is worth it and the flap pockets are right.

$798Retail
Compare OptionsShop New
Buck Mason Bruiser MotoCompare options →

Buck Mason

Bruiser Moto

Semi-vegetable tanned cowhide, which is the thing to notice. Most jackets at this price are chrome tanned, which is faster and cheaper and never really develops. Veg tan patinas. The two-stage dye means the color has depth instead of sitting on the surface, so when it scuffs you get tone rather than a bald spot. Bemberg lining, hand-burnished finish. I know a lot of you hate on Buck Mason, but a real biker jacket in cowhide under $900 at retail is genuinely hard to find, and the tassel pulls are a nice touch.

$698Retail
Compare OptionsShop New

BETTER

At Better, the leather stops being the variable. Both are full-grain or veg-tanned cowhide from serious tanneries. What you're choosing between is a jacket built to outlive the trend and a jacket built to be exactly right for this moment.

Ralph Lauren Leather NewsboyCompare options →

Ralph Lauren

Leather Newsboy

Full-grain cowhide, which is the phrase to look for and the reason this sits a tier up. Full-grain means the outer surface of the hide is intact, nothing sanded off to hide flaws, which is what "genuine leather" and "corrected grain" mean further down the ladder. It's why the thing patinas instead of just wearing out. The rest of the spec is where the money went: corozo buttons instead of plastic, custom brass hardware instead of nickel-plated zinc, moleskin-lined hand pockets, cupro and cotton sleeve lining. None of that shows in a photo, all of it shows in five years. Also note they publish full measurements, including a 34.5" sleeve, which is long. This is cut for someone tall.

$1,295Retail
Compare OptionsShop New
Our Legacy Mini JacketCompare options →

Our Legacy

Mini Jacket

Vegetable-tanned Italian cowhide with a Lampo zip. Two things worth knowing. Veg tanning takes weeks instead of hours and produces leather that actually develops with wear rather than sitting still, which is what the product copy is politely saying when it talks about the jacket becoming distressed over time. And Lampo is the Italian zipper maker that shows up on jackets three times this price. When a brand names the zip, they're telling you where the budget went.

The boxy cut is the other thing you're buying. This is a fashion silhouette, not an archive reproduction, and it will date faster than the Ralph Lauren. That's the trade: one of these is a jacket you keep for twenty years, the other is a jacket that looks right now.

$1,870Retail
Compare OptionsShop New

BEST

Bottega Veneta Nappa BlousonCompare options →

Bottega Veneta

Nappa Blouson

The cleanest cut in the piece and the one I'd actually wear. Lightweight nappa lambskin, ribbed cuffs and hem, no hardware doing anything except the zip. Made in Italy. There's almost nothing in the spec, which is the point: at this level the money is in the pattern and the leather selection, and neither shows up as a bullet. It's also the most fragile jacket here. Lightweight lambskin is beautiful and it does not want to be your everyday jacket in the rain.

~$5,750Retail
Compare OptionsShop New
Phoebe Philo AviatorCompare options →

Phoebe Philo

Aviator

Lamb leather, mottled finish, high funnel neck, pitched to sit higher at the back. That last detail is a pattern decision most brands wouldn't bother with, and it's what separates design from styling. This is also a women's jacket, which is the entire subject of the next issue, so I'll leave it there except to say the aviator cut is one of the ones that translates.

~$4,300Retail
Compare OptionsShop New

Where the line is

Look at what the Best tier has in common. Both are lambskin. Every jacket at the top of this ladder is made from the softest, thinnest, least durable hide on this list.

That's not a scam and it's not an accident. Above a certain price you stop buying durability and start buying hand, pattern, and name. The Buck Mason cowhide will outlast both of these. The Ralph Lauren full-grain will still look good in fifteen years. The Bottega will be beautiful for five and then it will be a beautiful old jacket.

So the line isn't where I expected it. It's between Better and Best. Everything up to Our Legacy is buying you more jacket. Everything past it is buying you a specific idea of yourself.

We’re all wearing a costume. The only question worth answering is whether you’re paying for the jacket or the story it tells about you.

Keep reading

The next issue, when it's ready.